СИНДРОМ ПОДЪЕМА КИТАЯ? ФОРМИРОВАНИЕ НАЦИОНАЛЬНЫХ ШКОЛ ТЕОРИИ МЕЖДУНАРОДНЫХ ОТНОШЕНИЙ В АЗИИ

Подъем Китая стал одним из ключевых вопросов изучения в теории международных отношений. В то же время эта тенденция стимулирует изменения в структуре самой, прежде западноцентричной, дисциплины. Она стимулирует рефлексию происходящих изменений в формирующейся китайской школе ТМО. В более широком плане становление китайской теории международных отношений заставляет другие азиатские страны также концептуализировать свое положение в мире, для предотвращения перспективы интеллектуального подчинения своему растущему соседу. Такое теоретизирование опирается на национальные традиции осмысления международной политики (по большей части игнорируемые на Западе). Развитие этой тенденции способствует подлинной либерализации дисциплины. 

1. Acharya A., Buzan B. Why Is There No Non- Western International Relations Theory? // International Relations of the Asia-Pacific. 2007. Vol. 7. P. 287–312.

2. Little R. The English School’s Contribution to the Study of International Relations // European Journal of International Relations. 2000. 6, 3. P. 395–422.

3. Cho, Young Chul. Recent Discourses on Constructing a Korean National School of IR: A Reality Check // Re-examination of Non- Western International Relations Theories (Kyoto Working Paper on Area Studies 118 [G-COE Series 116]) / eds. Shiro Sato, Ikeda Josuke, Ching-Chanh Chen, and Young Chul Cho. Kyoto: Center for Southeast Asian Studies, Kyoto University, 2011. P. 66–94.

4. Hui V.T. War and State Formation in Ancient China and Early Modern Europe. Cambridge University Press, 2005 ; Ng-Quinn M. China and International Systems: History, Structures, Processes. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Government, Harvard University, 1978.

5. Kang D. East Asia Before the West: Five Centuries of Trade and Tribute. New York: Columbia University Press, 2010 ; Tan Ch., Uberoi P. The Rise of Asian Giants: The Dragon- Elephant Tango. New Delhi : Anthem Press, 2009.

6. Agathangelou A.M., Ling L.H.M. Transforming World Politics: From Empire to Multiple Worlds. London : Routledge, 2009 ; Shih Ch. Navigating Sovereignty: World Politics Lost in China. London : Palgrave, 2003.

7. Yan Xuetong. Ancient Chinese Thought and Modern Chinese Power / ed. Daniel Bell and Zhe Sun. Trans. Edmund Ryden. Princeton : Princeton University Press, 2011 ; Paltiel J. Constructing Global Order with Chinese Characteristics: Yan Xuetong and the Pre-Qin Response to International Anarchy // Chinese Journal of International Politics. 2011. 4, 4. P. 375–403.

8. Zhao Tingyang. A Political World Philosophy in Terms of All-Under-Heaven (Tian-xia) // Diogenes. 2009. 56, no.1 (February): 5–18 ; Zhao Tingyang. Rethinking Empire from a Chinese Concept ‘All-under-Heaven’ (Tian-xia) // Social Identities. 2006. 12, no. 1 (January). P. 29–41.

9. Qin Yaqin. Rule, Rules, and Relations: Towards a Synthetic Approach to Governance // Chinese Journal of International Politics. 2011. 4, 2. P. 117–145.

10. Zaehner R.C. Hinduism. New York : Oxford University Press, 1962. P. 1–13.

11. Nandy A. The Intimate Enemy. New Delhi : Oxford University Press, 1983.

12. Behera N.Ch. Re-imagining IR in India // International Relations of the Asia-Pacific. 2007. 7 (August). P. 341–368.

13. Hwang Wei-lin. Civilizational Differences and Modernity: Rabindranath Tagore’s Political Ideals and His Perspective on Chinese Civilization (wenming chayi yu xiandaixing: taigeer de zhengzhi lixiang ji qi dui zhongguo wenming de qipan). Taipei: The Research and Educational Center for China Studies and Cross Taiwan-Strait Relations, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University, 2010 ; Yin Xinan. Tagore in the Perspective of World Civilization (shijie wenming shiye zhong de taigeer). Chengdu : Bashu Book Society, 2003.

14. Tagore R. Towards Universal Man. New York : Asia Publishing House, 1961. P. 61–63.

15. Gupta K.S. The Philosophy of Rabindranath Tagore. Surrey : Ashgate, 2004.

16. Nandy A. The Illegitimacy of Nationalism: Rabindranath Tagore and the politics of self. New Delhi : Oxford University Press, 1994.

17. Pande D.C. India’s Foreign Policy as an Exercise in Non-alignment: Nehru-Indira Period, 1946– 1976. Kanpur : Gyanodaya Prakashan, 1988.

18. Ibid ; Deshingkar G. The Nehru Years Revisited // Across the Himalayan Gap: An Indian Quest for Understanding China / ed. by Chung Tan. New Delhi : Gyan Pub. House, Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts, 1998.

19. Cotton J. Realism, Rationalism, Race: On the Early International Relation Discipline in Australia // International Studies Quarterly. 2009. 53, 3. P. 627–647.

20. Fitzgerald J. Big White Lie: Chinese Australians and White Australia. Sydney : University of New South Wales Press, 2007.

21. Moran A. Australia: Nation, Belonging and Globalization (Global Realities). London : Routledge, 2004.

22. Wang Gungwu. Community and Nation: Essays on Southeast Asia and the Chinese. Singapore: Heinemann Education Books, 1981 ; Dening G. Beach Crossing: Voyaging Across Time, Cultures and Self. Philadelphia : University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004 ; Barme G. On New Sinology. The China Heritage Center. URL: http://rspas.anu. edu.au/pah/chinaheritageproject/newsinology/ index.php, accessed March 21, 2010.

23. Hendrischke H. The Political Economy of China’s Provinces: Competitive and Comparative Advantage. London : Routledge, 1999 ; Edwards L., Roces M. Women’s Suffrage in Asia: Gender, Nationalism and Democracy. London : Routledge, 2004 ; He Baogang. Transnational Civil Society and the National Identity Question in East Asia // Global Governance. 2005. 10, 2. P. 227–246 ; Hillman B. Monasticism and the Local State: Autonomy and Authority in a Tibetan Prefecture // The China Journal. 2005. No. 54. P. 22–52 ; Goodman D. China Deconstructs: Politics, Trade and Regionalism. Oxford : Taylor & Francis, 2007 ; Mackerras C. China, Xinjiang and Central Asia: History, Transition and Crossborder Interaction into the 21st Century. Oxford : Taylor & Francis, 2009.

24. Tseng Yen-chung. Away from Centrism: Jonathan Unger, Baogang He and the Multople Agendas of Australia’s China Studies (aozhou zhongguo yanjiu de duoyanxing: yi ange ji he baogang de xuexi lichen wei li). Taipei : The Research and Educational Center for China Studies and Cross Taiwan-Strait Relations, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University, 2010 ; Chen Tzu-chieh, Yun-chan Wu. China Studies from South: A Study of John Fitzgerald and Contemporary Australian China Studies (nanfang zhongguo xue: fei yuhan yu dandai aozhou tese de zhongguo yanjiu). Taipei : The Research and Educational Center for China Studies and Cross Taiwan-Strait Relations, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University, 2010.

25. Kim M., Hodges H.J. Korea as a Clashpoint of Civilizations // Korea Observer. 2006. 37, 3 (Autumn). P. 513–545.

26. Kim S. The International Relations of Northeast Asia. Lanham, MD. : Roman & Littlefield, 2003 ; Kim S. North Korean Foreign Relations in the Post-Cold War World: Demystifying North Korea. Carlisle, PA : Strategic Studies Institute U.S. Army War Co, 2007.

27. Choi A. Future Tasks for International Relations Theorizing in South Korea. URL: http://docs. google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:UYqnk3tZ ZBQJ:www.kaisnet.or.kr/board09/download. asp%3Fidx%3D268+Future+Tasks+for+Int ernational+Relations+Theorizing+in+South +Korea&hl=zh-TW&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid= ADGEESgHYA2eXp4xpbNtGRTGRENVU lzINzR-C998btW-oRNp7-0mmermUDvIK szLKWXVp3M27s3g3pQ2I17r83_SEyOqW hGvwhxbAyPfdpnM8AWGk1OPRmuRKxmJqBp3c_ RZ02iBb8m&sig=AHIEtbQoRk0Y AYH9TNpiuotOVdAf9-ONFg accessed March 30, 2010 ; Chun Ch. Future Tasks for Developing the Field of International Relations in South Korea // The Korean Journal of International Relations. 2007. 46. P. 227–249 ; Min B.W. International Relations Theories and Korea // The Korean Journal of International Relations. 2007. 46. P. 37–66 ; Kook K.H., Young Ch.Yu. International Relations Studies in Korea: Retrospects and Prospects // Pacific Focus. 2009. 24, 2 (December). P. 402–421.

28. Ku D. Korean International Relations in the Colonial Period and the Question of Independence // Korea Journal. 1998. 4 (Winter). P. 90–129 ; Cha V. Alignment Despite Antagonism: The United States-Korea-Japan Security Triangle. Stanford : Stanford University Press, 1999 ; Kang D. China Rising: Peace, Pow and Order in East Asia. New York : Columbia University Press, 2007.

29. Nam Ch. Relocating the U.S. Forces on the Korean Peninsula: Strained Alliance and Emerging Partnership in the Changing Defense Posture. Presented at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association, Hilton Hawaiian Village, Honolulu, Hawaii (March 5, 2005). URL: http://www.allacademic.com/ meta/p71260_index.html accessed on March 30, 2010.

30. Chun H. Some Notes on the History of the Sino- Korean Relationship (Hankook gwa Jungkook: Han-Jung gwangyesa doroneui ilcheok) // Dongbanghakji. 1968. 9. P. 1–19.

31. Wu Cho-liu. The Asiatic Orphan (Yaxiya guer). Taipei : Grass Root Press, 1995.

32. Wang Yao-chun. Entering the Strategic Triangle: The International Theory That Identifies with Taiwan (jinru zhanlue sanjiao: renting Taiwan de guoji zhengzhi xue). Taipei : Hanlu, 2005.

33. Yang Kuo-shu, Chung-i Wen . Contextualizing Social Behavioral Science Research for the Chinese Context (shehui xingwei kexue yanjiu de zhongguo hua). Taipei : Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica, 1982.

34. Song Kuo-cheng. Postcolonial Discourses: From Fanon to Said (houzhimin lunshu: cong fanon dao sayide). Taipei : Qinsong, 2003 ; Mo Tahua. Constructive International Relations Theory and Security Studies (jiangouzhuyi guojia guanxi lilun yu anquan yanjiu). Taipei : Shihying, 2003 ; Teng, Hsiu-lun. Women and the United Nation (nyuxing yu lianhe guo). Taipei : Yangchi, 2003 ; Hwang, Ching-Chane. “Mature Anarchy, Clash of Civilizations and Globalization: The Narrow Research Agendas of the Mainstream International Relations Theory” (chengshou wuzhengfu zhuangtai, wenming chongtulun yu quanqiuhua: zhuliu guoji guanxi lilun zhi pianxia yanjiu yichneg) // Cross and International Affairs Quarterly. 2005. 2, 1. P. 81–106.

35. Lin Hsuan-Hsiang Sean. Democracy, Teleology, and Regime Pluralism. Present at the conference on Democratizing International Relations: New Thinking, Doing and Being, Kaohsiung 3.11 — 3.12.2009.

36. Lee T., Nakajima M. The Strategy for Asia (yazhou de zhilue) Luo and Yang (trans.). Taipei : Yuan-Liou Publishing Co, 2000 ; Ke Yigeng. Lee Tenghui: Taiwan’s Statesman (Taiwan zhengzhijia li denghui). Trans. Hsiao Pao-hui. Taipei : Vanguard, 2008.

37. Hwang Chun-chieh. Confucianism and Modern Taiwan (luxue yu xiandai Taiwan). Beijing : Chinese Social Science Press, 2001 ; Yu Yingshih. I Am Not Neo-Confucian. 2009. URL: http://www.wenhuacn.com/news_article. asp?classid=20&newsid=8241, accessed on 2010.3.26.

38. Jiang Yi-hua. Reflections on Discourses on National Identities in Contemporary Taiwan (dangqian Taiwan guojia renton lunshu zhi fanxing), Taiwan : A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies. 1998. 29. P. 163–229 ; Shih Chih-yu. Democracy Made in Taiwan: The “Success State” as a Political Theory. Lanham : Lexington, 2007.

39. Ling L.H. M., Ching-Chane Hwang, Boyu Chen. Subaltern Straits: ‘Exit’, ‘Voice’, and ‘Loyalty’ in the United States-China-Taiwan Relations // International Relations of the Asia-Pacific. 2010. 10. P. 33–59.

40. Chong A. Southeast Asia: Theory between Modernization and Tradition // International Relations of the Asia-Pacific. 2007. 7: 391–425.

41. Leo S. China and the ASEAN States: The Ethnic Chinese Dimension. Singapore : Marshall Cavendish Academic, 2005 ; Wang Gungwu. Great China and the Chinese overseas // The China Quarterly. 1993. 136, special issue (December). P. 926–948 ; Wang Gungwu. A Short History of Nanyang Chinese. Singapore : Eastern Universities Press, 1959.

42. Leo S. Ethnic Chinese in Contemporary Indonesia. Singapore : Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 2009 ; Wang Yao-chun. Entering the Strategic Triangle: The International Theory That Identifies with Taiwan (jinru zhanlue sanjiao: renting Taiwan de guoji zhengzhi xue). Taipei : Hanlu, 2005.

43. Civilizations in World Politics: Plural and Pluralist Perspectives / ed. Katzenstein Peter. London : Routledge, 2009 ; Katzenstein P. A World of Religions: Asia and Europe in American Imperium. New York : Columbia University Press, 2005.

44. Leo S. Understanding the Ethnic Chinese in Southeast Asia. Singapore : Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 2007.

45. Lee S. The Malaysian Kwong Wah Newspapers’ View on China: Between the Chinese Overseas and Guest Chinese (malaixiya guang hua ribao de zhongguo renshi: zai huaren yu huaqiao liang zhong shenfen zhi jian). Taipei : The Research and Educational Center for China Studies and Cross Taiwan-Strait Relations, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University, 2009.

46. Acharya A. Seeking Security in the Dragon’s Shadow: China and Southeast Asia in the Emerging Asian Order. Working Paper Series 44, Institute for Defence and Strategic Analysis (March). 2003.

47. Haacke J. Enhanced Interaction with Myanmar and the Project of a Security Community: Is ASEAN Refining or Breaking with Its Diplomatic and Security Culture? // Contemporary Southeast Asia. 2005. 27, 2. P. 188–216.

48. Petersson M. Myanmar in EU-ASEAN Relations // Asia-Europe Journal. 2006. 4, 4: 563–581.

49. Linantud J. L. The 2004 Philippine Elections: Political Change in an Illiberal Democracy // Contemporary Southeast Asia. 2005. 27. P. 80–101 ; Towards Illiberal Democracy in Pacific Asia / ed. D. Bell. London : Macmillan, 1996.

50. Katanyuu R. Beyond Non-interference in ASEAN — the Association’s Role in Myanmar’s National Reconciliation and Democratization // Asian Survey. 2006. 46, 6. P. 825–845 ; Beeson M. ASEAN Plus Three and the Rise of Reactionary Regionalism // Contemporary Southeast Asia. 2003. 25, 2. P. 251–268.

51. Williams D. Defending Japan’s Pacific War: The Kyoto School Philosophers and Post-White Power. London : Routledge, 2005.

52. Kōsaka M. The Standpoint of World History and Japan (Sekaishiteki tachiba to Nihon). Tōkyō : Chūō Kōronsha, Shōwa, 1943 ; Kōyama I. The Philosophy of World History (Sekaishi no tetsugaku). Tōkyō : Iwanami Shoten, 1942.

53. Pan-Asianism in Modern Japanese History: Colonialism, Regionalism and Borders / eds. S. Saaler, J. V. Koschmann. London : Routledge, 2007 ; Globalism, Regionalism and Nationalism: Asia in Search of Its Role in the 21st Century / ed. Y. Yamamoto. Oxford : Blackwell, 1999.

54. Tanaka St. Japan’s Orient: Rendering Pasts into History. Berkeley : University of California Press, 1993.

55. Huang Chia-ning, Chih-yu Shih. No Longer Oriental: Self and European Characteristics in Japan’s Views on China (bu zai dongfang: riben zhongguo renshi zong de ziwoxing yu ouzhouxing). Taipei : The Research and Educational Center for China Studies and Cross Taiwan-Strait Relations, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University, 2009.

56. Ong G. G. Building an IR theory with ‘Japanese Characteristics’: Nishida Kitaro and ‘Emptiness // Millennium. 2004. 33, 1. P. 35–58.

57. Nakamura Y. Nishida Kitaro (Xitian jiduolang). Bu Chongdao and Liu Wenzhu. Trans. Beijing : Sanlian, 1992.

58. Heisig, J. Philosophers of Nothingness: an Essay on the Kyoto School. London : Routldge, 2001 ; Fujita M. The ‘Place’ Comes from the Fundamental Thinking (“changsuo” laizi genbenchu de sikao) // The Deconstruction and Reconstruction of Subjectivity: New Interpretations of the Japanese History of Thoughts (benti de jiegou chongjian: dui riben sixiang shi de xin quanshi) / ed. Cheng Zhongying. Shanghai: Shanghai Social Science Academy Press, 2005.

59. Calichman R. Overcoming Modernity: Cultural Identity in Wartime Japan. New York : Columbia University Press, 2008 ; Takeuchi Yo., Calichman R. What Is Modernity? Writings of Takeuchi Yoshimi. New York : Columbia University Press, 2005.

60. Yūzō M. China as Method (Hōhō to shite no Chūgoku). Tōkyō : Tōkyō Daigaku Shuppankai, 1989.

61. Koyasu N. What Is It about Overcoming Modernity (“Kindai no chōkoku” to wa nani ka). Tōkyō : Seidosha, 2008.

62. Goto-Jones Ch. Political Philosophy in Japan: Nishida, the Kyoto School, and Co-Prosperity. Routledge (Leiden Series in Modern East Asia), 2005.

63. Chen kwang-hsing. On the Possibility of an East Asian Discourse (guanyu dongya lunshu de kenengxing). Shucheng (Book Castle) December, 2004. P. 35–45 ; Sun Ge. The Space of Pervasive Subjectivities (zhuti misan de kongjian). Nanchang : Jiangxi Education Press, 2003.

64. Between Understanding and Misunderstanding: Problems and Prospects for International Cultural Exchanges / ed. Sugiyama Yasushi New York : Greenwood Press, 1990.

65. Iriye A. Cultural Internationalism and World Order. Baltimore : The John Hopkins University Press, 1997.

66. A New East Asia: Toward a Regional Community / eds. K. Mōri, K. Hirano. Singapore : NUS Press, 2007.

67. Shimizu K. et al. Is There a Japanese IR?: Seeking an Academic Bridge through Japanese History of International Relations. Research Series 5. Kyoto : Afrasian Centre for Peace and Development Studies, Ryukoku University, 2008.