Anti-Immigrant Eurosceptic Worldview in Estonia: a Comparison of Russian-Speaking and Estonian-Speaking Communities

This article analyzes the transformation of the attitude of the Russian-speaking and Estonian-speaking communities of Estonia towards the reception of refugees from the 1990s until the present day. A comparison is made of the attitude towards immigrants of various origins (African, Asian, Ukrainian refugees, entrants from Russia) by ethnic Estonians with the perception of them by local Russian-speaking residents of this Baltic state. The author examines the reasons for the negative and positive perception of Estonians towards immigrants of various origins. It is noted that there is a direct connection between the current perception of immigrants in Estonia and the historical past of this country. The paper describes the sharp increase in Euroscepticism in Estonia after the start of the European migration crisis in 2015, as well as the serious joint opposition of the state’s authorities and its residents to the refugee distribution quotas imposed by the European Commission. In addition to the similarities in the approaches of the two largest communities on the issue of refugees, the author also identified a number of significant differences on this topic, which is sensitive for all Estonians. The paper concludes that the refugee crisis and anti-immigrant Eurosceptic worldview have largely united ethnic Russians and Estonians living in Estonia in the face of a “common threat”. It is also justified that the present warm and hospitable attitude of ethnic Estonians towards Ukrainian refugees in the medium term may be replaced by “fatigue” and apathy towards them.

1. Astapova A. (2020) Ferroconcrete cases, sausage migrants, and Santa Barbara: self- reflexive metaphors among Russian-speaking refugees in Estonia. Journal of Baltic Studies 51:1, 87-103. DOI: 10.1080/01629778.2019.1623277.

2. Bîrzea C. (1996) Human Rights and Minorities in the New European Democracies: Educational and Cultural Aspects. Report on the Workshop Held at Lohusalu (Estonia) 20-23 October 1994. Council of Europe. 143 p.

3. Hallik K. (2002) Nationalizing Policies and Integration Challenges. The Challenge of the Russian Minority: Emerging Multicultural Democracy in Estonia. M. Lauristin, M. Heidmets (eds.). Tartu: Tartu University Press. 396 p.

4. Jauhiainen J., Erbsen H. (2023) Multilevel governance in the temporal protection and integration of Ukrainians within the European Union: the case of Estonia. Journal of European Integration 45(3): 413-430. DOI: 10.1080/07036337.2023.2190109.

5. Kasekamp A., Madisson M.-L., Wierenga L. (2018) Discursive Opportunities for the Estonian Populist Radical Right in a Digital Society. Problems of Post-Communist 66: 1-12.

6. Kuus M. (2007) Geopolitics Reframed, Security and Identity in Europe’s Eastern Enlargement. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. 224 p.

7. Makarychev A., Ploom I. (2019) A Etnopolítica da Crise dos Refugiados: uma Investigação dos Debates Estónios. Relações Internacionais 62: 39-56. DOI: 10.23906/ri2019.62a04.

8. Makarychev A., Yatsyk A. (2017) Estonia and the refugees: political discourses and artistic representations. Global Affairs 3(1): 45-57. DOI: 10.1080/23340460.2017.1316593. (In Portuguese)

9. Paju I. (2019) Tõrjutud mälestused. Tallinn: Gallus. 287 lk. (In Estonian).

10. Peiker P. (2016) Estonian Nationalism through the Postcolonial Lens. Journal of Baltic Studies 47(1): 120-123. DOI: 10.1080/01629778.2015.1103516.

11. Petsinis V. (2019) Identity Politics and Right-Wing Populism in Estonia: The Case of EKRE. Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 25(2): 211-230. DOI: 10.1080/13537113.2019.1602374.

12. Põlluaas H. (2019) Sotsid: Interrinde teine tulemine. Tallinn: Grenader Kirjastus. 432 lk. (In Estonian).

13. Smith D. J. (1998) Russia, Estonia and the Search for a Stable Ethno-Politics. Journal of Baltic Studies 29(1): 3-18. DOI: 10.1080/01629779700000191.

14. Tinn E. (2013) Lääne tsivilisatsioonist ja Euroopa tupikseisust. Tallinn: Tammerraamat. 392 lk. (In Estonian).

15. Vallaste K. (2004) Euroopa Liiduga liitumise vastane liikumine Eestis. Riigikogu Toimetised 9: 123-129. (In Estonian).

16. Veebel V. (2015) Balancing Between Solidarity and Responsibility: Estonia in the EU Refugee Crisis. Journal of Baltic Security 1(2): 28-61. DOI: 10.1515/jobs-2016-0020.

17. Veebel V., Ploom I. (2023) Estonian Fears, Hopes and Efforts: The Russian War against Ukraine. The Winter of Russia’s Discontent. Russia’s Futures from Within and Without. S. Šrāders, G.S. Terry (eds.). Tartu: University of Tartu Press. Pp. 142-155.

18. Wierenga L. (2017) Russians, Refugees and Europeans: What Shapes the Discourse of the Conservative People’s Party of Estonia? Uptake 6: 1-20. Available at: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/141514828.pdf (accessed: 10 November 2023).

19. Witt E., Nurk J.L., Lill I. (2023). From Zero to Hero? Changes in the Estonian Context for Refugees. Rebuilding Communities After Displacement. Hamza, M., Amaratunga, D., Haigh, R., Malalgoda, C., Jayakody, C., Senanayake, A. (eds.). Springer, Cham. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-031-21414-1_3.

20. Yatsyk A. (2018): A Popular Geopolitics of the Refugee Crisis in Europe: The Re-actualization of Identity-driven Geopolitical Narratives in Estonia. Geopolitics 23(4): 803-822. DOI: 10.1080/14650045.2018.1486300.

21. Vorotnikov V.V. (2017) Strany Baltii v uslovijah Brexit: evrooptimizm vs evroskepticizm [The Baltic States in the Context of Brexit: Euro-Optimism vs Euroscepticism]. Kontury global’nyh transformacij: politika, jekonomika, pravo [Outlines of Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, Law] 10(1): 122-140. DOI: 10.23932/2542-0240-2017-10-1-122-140. (In Russian).

22. Evropejskij sojuz na pereput’e: nereshennye problemy i novye vyzovy (politicheskie aspekty) [European Union at a Crossroads: Unresolved Problems and New Challenges (Political Aspects)] (2016) N.K. Arbatova, A.M. Kokeev (eds.). Moscow: Institute of World Economy and International Relations of the Russian Academy of Sciences. 232 p. (In Russian).

23. Il’in V.I. (2016) Narva kak transnacional’nyj ostrov (interpretacija interpretatora) [Narva as a Transnational Island (Interpreter’s Interpretation)]. Zhurnal sociologii i social’noj antropologii [Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology] 19(3): 207-214. (In Russian).

24. Kaveshnikov N.Ju. (2021) Evropejskij sojuz: istorija, instituty, dejatel’nost’ [European Union: History, Institutions, Activities]. Moscow: Aspekt Press. 368 p. (In Russian).

25. Mezhevich N.M. (2020) Put’ Pribaltiki: ot nacionalizma k avtoritarizmu, ot avtoritarizma k glorifikacii fashizma: nauchnyj doklad [The Path of the Baltics: from Nationalism to Authoritarianism, from Authoritarianism to the Glorification of Fascism: Scientific Report]. Saint Petersburg: Publishing and Printing Center of the North-West Institute of Management of RANEPA. 54 p. (In Russian).

26. Meshherjakov D.Ju. (2019) Ponjatie populizma v sovremennoj anglosaksonskoj i germanskoj politicheskoj nauke [The Concept of Populism in Modern Anglo-Saxon and German Political Science]. Vestnik Rossijskogo universiteta druzhby narodov. Serija: Politologija [Bulletin of the Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia. Series: Political Science] 21(4): 755- 764. DOI: 10.22363/2313-1438-2019-21-4-755-764. (In Russian).

27. Simonjan R.H. (2004) Novyj Baltijskij subjetnos – «Evrorusskie» [The New Baltic Sub- Ethnos – “Euro-Russians”]. Sociologija vlasti [Sociology of Power] 2: 59-76. (In Russian).

28. Rajk K. (2014) Moja Narva: mezhdu dvuh mirov [My Narva: between Two Worlds]. Tartu: Petrone Print: 286. (In Russian).

29. Tambi S.A. (2023) Model’ «mjagkogo» i «zhestkogo» evroskepticizma: jestonskij kejs [Model of “Soft” and “Hard” Euroscepticism: Estonian Case]. Sovremennaya Evropa [Contemporary Europe] 5(119): 211-219. DOI: 10.31857/S0201708323050170. (In Russian).

30. Terebov A.V. (2020) Evroskepticizm vo Francii. Ugroza Freksita na fone pandemii COVID-19 [Euroscepticism in France. The Threat of Frexit amid the COVID-19 Pandemic]. Mirovaja politika [World Politics] 4: 53-64. DOI: 10.25136/2409-8671.2020.4.34357. (In Russian).

31. Furman D.E., Zadorozhnjuk Je.G. (2004) Pritjazhenie Baltii (baltijskie russkie i baltijskie kul’tury) [The Attraction of the Baltic (Baltic Russian and Baltic Cultures)]. Mir Rossii. Sociologija. Jetnologija [World of Russia. Sociology. Ethnology] 13(3): 98-130. (In Russian).

32. Hrishkevich T.G. (2017) Pribaltika v uslovijah migracionnogo krizisa 2014-2016 gg. [The Baltics in the Context of the Migration Crisis of 2014-2016] Obshhestvo: politika, jekonomika, parvo [Society: Politics, Economics, Law] 12: 33-37. (In Russian).