Preview

Comparative Politics Russia

Advanced search

ON THE “IRRATIONAL” IN POLITICAL SCIENCE AND IN POLITICAL PRACTICES

https://doi.org/10.18611/2221-3279-2018-9-2-93-104

Abstract

The author, parting from the premise that the world political analysts failed to foresee some prominent political changes of the recent times, comes to the conclusion about the inadequacy of the existing methods of political analysis and forecasting. Some recent scientifi c works by Russian and foreign specialists made him think that a purely rationalist approach to the world studies, that has been used since the times of the Renascence, partly exhausted itself. Along with the Russian authors Baranovski and Bogaturov, the Author thinks, that from now on our political analysis should be enriched by the introduction of some elements of a so called “natural – chaotic essence”, which infl uences the world events through the element of “happening”. The core of such an approach could include: 1) the recognition of a partial inadequacy of purely rationalist methods in our assessment of human nature and social phenomena; 2) the transference of the center of gravity in our social studies from economic to national-ethnic, culturological and civilizational aspects; 3) a wider use of historic analogies in the studies of all the problems of modern international relations. A linear character of our political forecasting will most evidently suffer because of that. Nevertheless, it would contribute to the elaboration of a more stereoscopic, complex view on the international relations as a whole and, particularly, on such problems as terrorism, illegal migration, separatism, and so on. The Author agrees with the thesis of some Occidental analysts (Bernard Yak, e.g.) that we should learn to “dutifully live” with certain irrational phenomena of political life (e.g. – nationalism), by purposely searching for and the accentuation of their “brighter” sides in the detriment of “dark” ones. The main prerequisite of such an accentuation, according to the Author, should be a wider use of education and culture. Culture, as a “positive” irrational actor (in all its demonstrations, including the political culture) should be seen as a promoter of a more active information strategy of Russia in the world arena. A shift for such a strategy is utterly necessary because a continuation of a “defensive” policy in this sphere can lead to signifi cant losses.

About the Author

Boris F. Martynov
MGIMO University
Russian Federation
Dr. of Political Science, Professor, Head of Department of International Relations and Foreign Policy of Russia


References

1. Bainton, R. 1917 Russia`s Year of Revoluton. London: Robinson, 2005. 315 p.

2. Baranovski, V.G.; Bogaturov, A.D. Sovremennye globalnye problem (Modern Global Problems). Moscow: Aspect-press, 2010. 349 p.

3. Beugelsdijk, S.; Maseland, R. Kul’tura v ekonomicheskoi nauke (Culture in Economics). Moscow: Institut Gaidara, 2016. 445p.

4. Bordachev, T.V. Pushki aprelia ili vozvrashenie srtategicheskoi frivolnosti (The April Guns or the Return of the Strategic Frivolity) // Rossia v globalnoi politike, 2017, Vol. XV, No. 3, pp. 23-34.

5. Burley, M. Blood and Rage. A Cultural History of Terrorism. London: Harper Perennial, 2009. 581 p.

6. Figes, O. A People`s Tragedy. The Russian Revolution. 100th Anniversary Edition. London: The Bodley Head, 2017. 923 p.

7. Kak vazhno byt serioznym: mir nag rani nepopravimogo (How it is Important to be Serious: The World on the Verge of Uncorrectable) // Doklad mezhdunarodnogo diskussionnogo kluba “Valdai” (Report of the International Club “Valdai”). Moscow, 2017. 20 p.]

8. Kliksberg, B.A. Mitos y realidades sobre la criminalidad en América Latina. Buenos Aires: Siglo, 2006. 215 p.

9. Martynov, B.F. (ed.) Transgranichnyi terrorism. Ugrozy bezopasnosti I Imperativy mezhdunarodnogo sotrudnichestva. Latinoamericanskii vektor (Transnational Terrorism. Threats to the Security and the Imperatives of International Cooperation. Latin American Vector). Moscow: Nauka, 2006. Nazarenko, K.B. Flot, Revolutzia I vlast` v Rossii: 1917-1921 (Navy, Revolution and Power in Russia: 1917- 1921). Moscow: Kvadriga, 2011. 483 p.

10. Nikonov, V.A. Krushenie Rossii. 1917 (The End of Russia. 1917). Mode of access: fi ctionbook.ru/static/ trials/06/18/14/06181443,a4.pdf

11. Taylor, Ed. The Fall of Dynasties. The Collapse of the Old Order. NewYork: Yale University Press, 1963. 585p.

12. Thaleb, N.N. Chernyi lebed’. Pod znakom nepredskazuemosti (The Black Swan. The Impact of Highly Improbable). Moscow: Ko libri, 2010. 735 p.

13. Yak, B. Natsionalizm i moral’naia psikhologiia obshchestva (Nationalism and the Moral Psychology of Community). Moscow, Institut Gaidara, 2017. 735 p.


Review

For citations:


Martynov B.F. ON THE “IRRATIONAL” IN POLITICAL SCIENCE AND IN POLITICAL PRACTICES. Comparative Politics Russia. 2018;9(2):93-104. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.18611/2221-3279-2018-9-2-93-104

Views: 661


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2221-3279 (Print)
ISSN 2412-4990 (Online)