THE POLEMOGENIC WAVE OF REVOLUTIONS 1917-1927 AS A HISTORICAL LABORATORY
Abstract
Abstract. The main link between revolutions in a polemogenic wave is participation of correspondent states in a common war (Πόλεμος — war, Γέννηση — birth). The polemogenic wave caused by the First World War includes successful revolutions (with the change of power) in Russia, Germany, Hungary, the success of some national liberation movements of Irish people, Czechs, Slovaks, South Slavs, Poles, Finns, the defeat of such movements of Ukrainians, Georgians, Armenians, peoples of Turkestan, the establishment of regimes of various types and with different stability. The article presents an approach to identify causes of different types of dynamics and the consequences of revolutionary events in within the wave. The approach includes comparisons using methods of similarity and difference, as well as the application of binarization and Boolean algebra according to Ch. Ragin's method. The application of this approach makes it possible to put forward hypotheses about causes and patterns of revolutionary dynamics and consequences in the polemogenic wave: what determines inclusion of a society into the wave, the level of loyalty of ethnic provinces in relation to their empire, success and failure of revolutions, existence and absence of civil war, relationship between revolution and religion, nature and fate of the cultural avant-garde.
About the Author
Nikolai Sergeyevich RozovInstitute of Philosophy and Law of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Chair for Social Philosophy and Political Science, Department of Philosophy, Novosibirsk State University, Chair for International Relations and Regional Studies, Novosibirsk State Technological University
Russian Federation
References
1. Адаскина Н. Закат авангарда в России. В кн.: Поэзия и живопись: Сб. трудов памяти Н. И. Харджиева. — М.: Языки русской культуры, 2000. С. 148-158. (Adaskina N. Zakat avangarda v Rossii. In.: Poeziya i zhivopis: Sb. trudov pamyati N. I. Hardzhieva) (Decay of the avant-garde in Russia. In: Poetry and painting: Works for memory of N. I. Khardzhiev) — Moscow: Yazyki russkoy kulturi, 2000. P. 148-158.
2. Великая утопия. Русский и советский авангард 1915-1952. — Берн-Москва, 1995. (Velikaya utopiya. Russkiy i sovetskiy avangard 1915-1952) (Great Utopia. The Russian and Soviet avant-garde of 1915-1952) — Bern-Moscow, 1995.
3. Голдстоун Дж. К теории революции четвертого поколения // Логос, 2006. № 5. С. 58 103. Original: Goldstone, Jack A. Toward a fourth generation of revolutionary theory // Annual Review of Political. Science. 2001, no 4: P. 139–87.
4. Дэвис Н. История Европы. М.: АСТ: Транзиткнига, 2005. Original: Davis, Norman. Europe: A History. — Oxford University Press, 1996.
5. Итальянский анархо-синдикализм до победы фашизма, 2009. (Italyanskiy anarho-sindikalizm do pobedi fashizma) (Italian anarcho-syndicalism before the victory of fascism) Original: ’Unione Sindacale Italiana tra sindacalismo di base e trasformazione sociale // Quaderni di Lotta di Classe, no 1, 1997. http://aitrus.info/node/168. http://aitrus.info/node/168.
6. Коллинз Р. Социология философий: глобальная теория интеллектуального изменения. Новосибирск: Сибирский Хронограф. 2002. Original: Collins, Randall. Sociology of philosophies: A global theory of intellectual change. — Harvard University Press, 1999.
7. Коллинз Р. Макроистория: опыты социологии большой длительности. М.: УРСС, 2015. Original: Collins, Randall. Macrohistory: essays in sociology of the long run. — Stanford University Press, 2000.
8. Платошкин Н. Н. История Мексиканской революции. Выбор пути 1917-1928 гг. — М.: Университет Дмитрия Пожарского : Русский Фонд содействия образованию и науке, Т. 2. 2011. (Platoshkin N. N. Istoriya Meksikanskoy revolyucii. Vybor puti 1917-1928) (The History of the Mexican revolution. The choice of the path 1917 1928) — Moscow: Dmitry Pozharsky University: Russian Foundation for the Promotion of Education and Science. Vol. 2. 2011.
9. Разработка и апробация метода теоретической истории. Серия “Теоретическая история и макросоциология”. Вып. 1. — Новосибирск: Наука: 2001. (Razrabotka i aprobaciya metoda teoreticheskoy istorii. Seriya ‘Teoreticheskaya istoriya i makrosociologiya’) (Development and approbation of the method of theoretical history. A series of ‘Theoretical History and Macrosociology’. Vol. 1. — Novosibirsk: Nauka: 2001.
10. Розов Н. С. Историческая макросоциология: методология и методы. — Новосибирск: НГУ, 2009. (Rozov, Nikolai S. Istoricheskaya makrosociologiya: metodologiya i metody) (Historical macrosociology: methodology and methods) — Novosibirsk: Novosibirsk State University, 2009.
11. Розов Н. С. Революционные волны в мировой истории: динамические модели роста и угасания // ЭКО, 2016, № 10. С. 78-95. (Rozov, Nikolai S. Revolyucionnie volni v mirovoy istorii: dinamicheskie modeli rosta i ugasaniya) (Revolutionary waves in the world history: dynamic models of growth and extinction) // ECO, 2016, no. 10. P. 78 95.
12. Туровская М. О выставке и каталоге. В кн.: Москва - Берлин. 1900-1960. М., 1996. (Turovskaya M. O vystavke i kataloge) (About the exhibition and catalog). In: Moscow - Berlin. 1900-1960. — Moscow, 1996.
13. Ушаков А. Г. Феномен Ататюрка. Турецкий правитель, творец и диктатор. М.: Центрполиграф, 2002. (Ushakov A. G. Fenomen Atatyurka. Tureckiy pravitel, tvorets i dictator) (The Atatürk Phenomenon. The Turkish ruler, creator and dictator) — Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2002.
14. Хренов Н. А. Возвращаясь к экспрессионизму: экспрессионизм и русская культура // Культура и искусство, 2013, № 3(15). С. 328-343. (Khrenov N. A. Vozvraschayas k ekspressionizmu: ekspressionizm i russkaya kultura) (Returning to expressionism: expressionism and Russian culture) // Kultura i iskusstvo, 2013, no 3(15). P. 328-343.
15. Beck C. J. The World-Cultural Origins of Revolutionary Waves Five Centuries of European Contention // Social Science History, 2011, vol. 35(2). P. 167–207.
16. Katz M. Revolutions and Revolutionary Waves. Palgrave Macmillan, 1999.
17. Ragin Ch. Constructing Social Research. Pine Forge Press, 1994.
Supplementary files
|
1. ПОЛЕМОГЕННАЯ ВОЛНА РЕВОЛЮЦИЙ 1917-1927 гг. КАК ИСТОРИЧЕСКАЯ ЛАБОРАТОРИЯ | |
| Subject | ||
| Type | Исследовательские инструменты | |
Download
(169KB)
|
Indexing metadata ▾ | |
Review
For citations:
Rozov N.S. THE POLEMOGENIC WAVE OF REVOLUTIONS 1917-1927 AS A HISTORICAL LABORATORY. Comparative Politics Russia. 2017;8(4).
Email this article 